• 3 Posts
  • 59 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: June 20th, 2023

help-circle


  • Or we can just implement a wealth tax like any reasonable nation.

    Yeah, the problem here is the implementation: you and I and most people here would benefit a little from a higher tax on billionaires, enough to motivate us to send a letter to our Congressional representatives and send a few bucks to whichever campaigning politicians promise to do it.

    Billionaires, in the meantime, stand to lose millions, or even tens of millions of dollars. Enough that it makes sense for them to start PACs, schmooze, and even bribe the Congressional representatives who’d be in charge of raising taxes. So even though there are hundreds of them and millions of us, they have greater means and motivation.














  • I admire the quippiness, but in this case, I heard the argument from Justin Brierley, explaining why, after ten years of hosting a podcast where believers (usually Christians) and unbelievers regularly engage in debate, he’s still a Christian. I actually enjoyed his show, and he seems like a nice guy, so I wouldn’t want to want to tell him to piss off.

    But I did roll my eyes when I heard this particular argument. It’s just evidence that smart people can believe very silly things, especially when it comes to religion.


  • Plus you are asking the wrong question. Does it matter if God exists if for those People who are comforted by their faith, their burden is lessened? The rest of it is irrelevant.

    That’s a separate category of apologetic (or a separate category of error): a lot of arguments for the existence of God are actually arguments for the utility of faith. Something like “Jesus gives me comfort” isn’t a good reason to think that Jesus exists, but it is an argument for why it’s useful to believe in him, whether he exists or not.

    Personally, I think that I’m better able to reach my goals (including finding comfort) if I base my beliefs on what’s actually true, not on whether they directly provide me comfort. But that’s me.