• 44 Posts
  • 238 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: March 23rd, 2022

help-circle











  • Telling that these grievances all center around foreign policy and trade. “We uphold the commitments we make!” YOU can uphold the commitments YOU make with MY tax dollars, I’ll just go and mind my own business.

    If I were to feel inclined to fight in the streets, it would be over the unlawful deportation of my neighbors, the genocide my government is financing, or my right to live as a woman and love who I deem fit. Ukraine will simply never be on my list of priorities.


  • It doesn’t matter if we consider China capable of solving our crises and absolving us of our sins. Painting China as complicit in Israel’s genocide is still completely unfair. You can argue that they have not done enough to stop the bleeding, but to say they’ve made no attempts, diplomatic or otherwise, to disrupt Israel’s genocide is simply untrue. It’s also not the job of the Chinese people or their government to clean up after our messes in the first place, especially at risk to their own national security and economic development.

    This kind of thinking, where major powers are culpable for all the evils of the entire world over, is rooted in the Anglo-American imperialist mindset. It makes sense for the Brits or the Yanks to feel responsible for all the suffering in the world. We are! But are Chinese people also meant to feel this way? If so, why?






  • “Maoists” are often westerners who have inherited decades of failure to achieve socialist revolutions in their own countries. They are free to spend too much time thinking about what socialism should be and could be in their heads rather than what socialism is. To many of us, socialism is simply the opposite of capitalism rather than its negation, therefore socialism must be the absence of the most hated features of capitalism in our experiences and opinions. China doesn’t always live up to these expectations.

    If you’ve never actually lived under socialism, you have no frame of reference for understanding how it’s different from capitalism. If you’ve never seen anything but capitalism, you don’t know how to identify its absence. This, more than anything, is what ultras struggle with. I think that’s something we can all relate to on some level, even if some have a better handle on it than others.